Back to Resources

Legal Malpractice Insurance Guide

1 in 4

attorneys will face a malpractice claim during their career

$54K

average defense cost per malpractice claim

43%

of claims involve missed deadlines or procedural errors

State Requirements Vary

Most states do not require malpractice insurance, but some mandate coverage or disclosure:

Mandatory Coverage:
  • • Idaho (minimum $100K)
  • • Oregon (minimum $300K)
  • • Some local jurisdictions
Disclosure Required:
  • • New Hampshire
  • • South Dakota
  • • Various local bar requirements

Types of Insurance Coverage

Professional Liability

Core malpractice coverage for legal services

Typical limits: $1M per claim, $3M aggregate

Coverage Includes:

  • Negligent acts, errors, or omissions in legal services
  • Failure to meet professional standards of care
  • Breach of fiduciary duty claims
  • Violation of professional ethics (coverage varies)
  • Defense costs and settlement expenses

Cyber Liability

Protection against data breaches and cyber attacks

Typical limits: $1M-$5M per occurrence

Coverage Includes:

  • Data breach notification and credit monitoring
  • Cyber extortion and ransomware attacks
  • Network security failure claims
  • Business interruption from cyber incidents
  • Regulatory fines and penalties (where permitted)

Employment Practices Liability

Coverage for employment-related claims

Typical limits: $1M-$2M per claim

Coverage Includes:

  • Wrongful termination and discrimination claims
  • Sexual harassment and workplace misconduct
  • Wage and hour violations
  • Retaliation and whistleblower claims
  • Third-party employment practices claims

General Liability

Basic business liability protection

Typical limits: $1M per occurrence, $2M aggregate

Coverage Includes:

  • Bodily injury and property damage claims
  • Premises liability for office locations
  • Personal and advertising injury
  • Medical expenses for injured parties
  • Legal defense costs

Policy Limits and Structure

Recommended Minimum Limits:

  • • Solo Practitioners: $1M per claim / $3M aggregate
  • • Small Firms (2-5 attorneys): $2M per claim / $4M aggregate
  • • High-Risk Practice Areas: $5M+ per claim
  • • Cyber Liability: $1M minimum, $5M preferred

Deductible Considerations:

  • • Typical deductibles: $2,500 - $25,000
  • • Higher deductibles reduce premium costs
  • • Consider financial ability to pay deductible
  • • Some policies have no deductible for defense costs

Insurance Carrier Selection

Financial Strength

Critical Priority

Insurer's ability to pay claims and remain solvent

Evaluation Criteria:

  • A.M. Best rating of A- or better preferred
  • Review of annual financial statements
  • Claims paying history and reputation
  • Regulatory actions or sanctions

Coverage Scope

High Priority

Breadth and depth of policy coverage

Evaluation Criteria:

  • Definition of professional services covered
  • Exclusions and limitations review
  • Prior acts coverage availability
  • Extended reporting period options

Claims Handling

High Priority

Quality of claims investigation and resolution

Evaluation Criteria:

  • Claims handling reputation and process
  • Average claim resolution timeframes
  • Settlement authority and philosophy
  • Panel counsel quality and experience

Premium Cost

Moderate Priority

Total cost of coverage and value proposition

Evaluation Criteria:

  • Premium competitiveness for coverage provided
  • Available discounts and rating factors
  • Payment options and financing
  • Rate stability and increase history

Factors Affecting Insurance Premiums

Practice Characteristics:

  • • Practice areas and specializations
  • • Years of experience and claims history
  • • Geographic location and jurisdiction
  • • Firm size and revenue
  • • Types of clients served

Risk Management Factors:

  • • Risk management practices and procedures
  • • Technology and cybersecurity measures
  • • Quality of case management systems
  • • Staff training and supervision
  • • Client intake and screening processes

Claims Prevention Strategies

Client Communication

  • Maintain regular, documented communication with clients
  • Respond promptly to client inquiries and concerns
  • Provide clear explanations of legal processes and timelines
  • Document all significant communications and decisions
  • Set realistic expectations about case outcomes

Case Management

  • Implement reliable calendaring and deadline tracking systems
  • Conduct thorough conflict checks for all new matters
  • Maintain complete and organized case files
  • Use checklists for routine legal procedures
  • Regularly review case status and progress

Professional Competence

  • Only accept matters within your area of competence
  • Stay current with legal developments through CLE
  • Consult with specialists when appropriate
  • Maintain current knowledge of ethics rules
  • Use updated legal research and forms

If You Receive a Malpractice Claim

Immediate Actions:

  • • Contact your insurance carrier immediately
  • • Do not admit fault or discuss the claim with anyone
  • • Preserve all relevant documents and communications
  • • Follow your insurer's instructions exactly
  • • Cooperate fully with the claims investigation

Critical: Report potential claims immediately, even if you believe they are without merit. Late reporting can void coverage.

Insurance Shopping Best Practices

Before Shopping:

  • • Assess your specific coverage needs
  • • Gather your practice and financial information
  • • Review current coverage and claims history
  • • Set budget parameters for premiums
  • • Identify preferred agents or brokers

When Comparing Quotes:

  • • Compare coverage limits and exclusions
  • • Review policy terms and conditions
  • • Evaluate carrier financial strength
  • • Consider total cost including deductibles
  • • Ask about available discounts